📰 The Pulse of Janesville and Rock County – Hypothetically Speaking

📰 August 15, 2025, | Vol. 1, Issue 24 (Approx. 2011 words – a twelve-minute read)

What’s Ahead? Information is Power, what works in Beloit might work elsewhere, and Every Idea Deserves the Light of Day and Public Discourse.

————————————————–

City of Janesville: Turning Missed Moments into Civic Momentum

Janesville – The City Planning staff have a habit of dropping essential information late. The Plan Commission agenda, for meetings held on Monday evenings, often does not hit the public until late Friday or over the weekend. That is typically after press deadlines, after meaningful public review, and even after commissioners themselves have had enough time to dig in and ask follow-up questions.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

We have dubbed this pattern “Information Interruptus.” It leaves decision-makers rushed, applicants without robust feedback, and residents locked out of the process until it is too late to matter. Over time, it breeds mistrust. This is a perception problem that shows up in data.

🗨️ Hypothetically Speaking…

If Agendas Served the People First, imagine if every Plan Commission agenda landed in inboxes one week ahead, with plain-language summaries so residents could weigh in early.

✅ Quick Scenario:

Agendas posted 14 days ahead, with clear descriptions of proposals.
Public Q&A portals opened immediately upon posting.
Commissioners and staff with time to respond before decisions.

✨ Vision:
More voices, fewer surprises.

📌 Reality:
Early agenda release is standard in well-run cities.

🚀 Challenge:
Will Janesville choose speed for staff… or access for citizens?

Janesville — The Survey Says… Now What?

The 2025 National Community Survey (NCS) confirms it:

Close-up of a sign

AI-generated content may be incorrect.

Strengths — 93% feel safe in their neighborhoods; 81% rate parks and recreation highly; mobility scores beat national averages.
Weaknesses — trust in city leadership, transparency, and opportunities for residents to influence decisions all scored below national benchmarks.

Fewer residents reported attending public meetings, contacting elected officials, or volunteering compared to national averages. These are not just numbers. They are symptoms of a civic culture that is more about service delivery than shared decision-making.

When the City Council received the survey results on July 28, the governance and participation data did not make it into the public discussion. The most important civic health indicators stayed in the footnotes. Key omissions because this segment of the survey offers insights into how well connects and engaged those surveyed feel in their dealings with City Hall.

🗨️ Hypothetically Speaking…

If Janesville Made Public Participation the Default, imagine a city where every meeting agenda, every survey result, and every budget line was easy to find, easy to understand, and open for real input before decisions were made.

✅ Quick Scenario:

Agendas posted two weeks ahead with plain-language summaries.
Full survey results published with side-by-side action plans.
“Data-to-dialogue” forums turning feedback into policy priorities.
Participatory budgeting so residents directly shape spending.
Youth and neighborhood councils feeding fresh ideas into city hall.

✨ Vision:
Every resident sees their fingerprint on the city’s future.

📌 Reality:
Other cities already do it — and their trust scores soar.

🚀 Challenge:
Will Janesville keep editing the story… or start writing it with its people?

Access to the Survey and a link to the more important database that is a treasure trove of information is available by searching for Janesville National Survey 2025 on your web browser. You will be directed to the City of Janesville Website with a link. Or you can go directly to: The NCS Report – Janesville, WI 2025 (custom benchmarks) | Tableau Public’ (click on link)

Beloit’s Playbook for Housing & Economic Development: Lessons Worth Replicating

Shorewest Realtors - Homes for Sale in Milwaukee, Waukesha and ...

City of Beloit – Conversations with City Manager Jerry Gabrielatos and Economic Development Director Drew Pennington make one thing clear: Beloit is not just responding to challenges, it is outpacing them. The secret? Adaptive financing tools, public-private constructive collaboration, and robust community participation.

Through collaborations with the Greater Beloit Economic Development Corporation, developers like Hendricks Development and others, as well as active public participation, the city is navigating the tough knot of supply, demand, equity, and opportunity with rare finesse.

Why it works: Beloit is agile enough to tailor deals quickly, yet substantial enough to wield serious financial leverage, making it a nimble and attractive partner for developers.

1. Strategic Use of Tax Increment Financing to Close Deals (~$7M invested)

The city created a $6 million Affordable Rental Housing Creation/Preservation Fund, funded by TIF districts, to fill financing gaps for developers using WHEDA tax credits.
In early 2025, the city allocated an additional $1 million from its TIF Housing Fund to incentivize new home developers—covering infrastructure costs to lower end-unit prices.

2. ARPA & Other City Funding—Backing the Strategy (~$15M ARPA + CDBG & more)

$15.2 million in ARPA funding, allocated as:
- $11.2M for infrastructure
- $2.95M for homelessness prevention and response
- $800K for nonprofit facility improvements
- $250K for youth recreation programming
Additional Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds supplement housing, neighborhood, and economic development programs.

Why it matters: Federal infusions like American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) allowed Beloit to accelerate timelines, de-risk projects, and strengthen the infrastructure foundation supporting growth.

3. Downtown Activation Through BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTS (BID) and Placemaking

The Downtown Beloit Association (BID) orchestrates marketing, beautification, events, and maintenance under a clear annual strategy.
With Hendricks Development’s revitalized building portfolio anchoring the core, private investment and public improvements reinforce one another.

Why it works: When the city consistently invests in place-making and partners align with that vision, momentum becomes self-sustaining.

4. Proactive Housing Production & Business Recruitment

TIF-fueled programs support both market-rate and affordable development.
The city releases land to builders and maintains a pipeline of units and parcels under contract.
Staff and partners actively recruit employees to both downtown and Gateway Business Park.

Why it works: Housing and job growth are treated as interdependent, ensuring that one supports the other.

Action Spotlight: Investing in Homeownership – Seed money at work in Beloit

$175,000 in 2024 HOME funds for homeownership assistance.
$75,000 already awarded to NeighborWorks Blackhawk Region, with a July 2025 recommendation for an additional $94,700—funding that has already helped local families purchase homes on Dewey, Prairie, McKinley, Forest, and Nelson Avenues.

What’s Next?

With ARPA dollars spent and state housing tax credits facing uncertainty, Beloit will need to lean even harder on:

Maximizing the flexibility of TIF tools
Pursuing federal competitive grants
Expanding private-sector capital partnerships (where Hendricks Development is already a model player)
Leveraging regional collaboration to spread infrastructure and housing costs across multiple funding sources

The city’s next chapter will depend on whether it can keep this nimble, deal-closing culture alive without the one-time funding boosts that made the last few years possible.

Hypothetically Speaking…

What if every community leveraged creative financing tools, fostered genuine public-private partnerships, and stayed nimble in changing funding climates? Imagine:

Downtowns maintained and marketed year-round with confidence.
Developers stepping in where there’s trust and momentum.
Communities anchored by homeownership, thriving businesses, and adaptable local government.

That is not just an idea—it is Beloit’s reality. And it is working.

🧠 Commentary:

This week’s Civics Education Corner: A Smarter Way to Hear from the Public — Without Losing Elected Control

When we first floated the idea of a greater role for citizen advisory committees, we did not expect the firestorm of reactions that followed. Some were thoughtful and contemplative.
Others landed squarely in the “How dare you challenge the authority of elected officials” camp.

One certainty, the purpose of Hypothetically Speaking is to provoke civic dialogue and get us to think. This was reinforced at a recent luncheon with a local attorney that echoed sentiments from a spirited email exchange with a respected former council member. Both reminded us:

Ideas without explanation are hard to defend.
Open minds still exist.
Shared goals unite people across different viewpoints.

How to Be a Better Listener - Smarter Living Guides - The New York ...

When we channel our energy toward the same outcome—representative governance in our democratic republic—there are few obstacles we cannot overcome. The key is equal access to the same information, so we are debating facts, not assumptions.

Our big idea of the week is below and intended to draw you into the conversation. Read, absorb, and react constructively. Constructive feedback is respectfully accepted and desired. After all, ideas become good or great when many heads around the table wrestling with the problem set.

The Big Idea: Community Expert Advisory Panel (CEAP)

Imagine a standing panel of 12–15 community volunteers—engineers, planners, teachers, small-business owners, scientists, neighborhood leaders—ready to lend their expertise.

They review major proposals, host public workshops, and give council and staff a sharper, more informed snapshot of public priorities.

Key point: Their role is advisory only.
Elected officials still decide.
The city manager still runs the day-to-day.

Existing staff refocused to research issues and facilitate small groups.

The difference? Decisions are made with better, broader information.

How It Works

1. Scoping –Staff drafts an issue summary. CEAP identifies outreach strategies and knowledge gaps.

2. Public Engagement – CEAP co-hosts pop-ups, neighborhood meetings, and online surveys—reaching beyond the usual audience.

3. Synthesis – Staff compiles trends; CEAP adds real-world context and professional expertise.

4. Council Review – Staff and CEAP present findings; council weighs the advice and makes the final call.

5. Closing the Loop – Publish a “You Spoke, We Listened” report so residents see results.

Why It Works in a Council–Manager Government

Protects Elected Authority – Council keeps decision-making power.
Supports the City Manager – Extends staff capacity without inflating budgets.
Cuts Consultant Costs – Local expertise replaces expensive boilerplate reports.
Improves Trust – Residents see how their voice shapes decisions.

Measuring Success

Each year, council reviews:

Participation numbers and diversity
Examples of policy changes shaped by public input
Cost savings from reduced consultant use

Transparency here builds confidence—inside city hall and in the community.

The Takeaway

A well-run citizen participation plan does not weaken elected authority—it strengthens it. When councils are informed by both professional staff and trusted community voices, cities become more resilient, more innovative, and more responsive. It is not radical or new. It is tried and evaluated in cities of comparable size to Janesville from across the country with strong, non-binding public participation programs (advisory/consultative only; elected officials keep decision-making authority):

Santa Monica, CA (~93k) — Longstanding innovation in civic engagement: the Office of Civic Wellbeing and data-driven Wellbeing Index to guide policy priorities; historic Public Electronic Network (PEN) pioneered broad online participation. Council retains final say.

Chapel Hill, NC (~61k) — Completed a 2023 Gap Analysis & Engagement Study to systematize inclusive outreach; maintains a formal Citizen Participation Plan for HUD programs. Engagement informs staff recommendations/council actions; it does not bind them.

Bellingham, WA (~93k) — Comprehensive Community Participation Plan (HUD), plus recent Parks & Recreation Communications & Engagement Plan emphasizing feedback loops and under-represented voices; Comp Plan adoption remains by ordinance of Council.

Bloomington, IN (~79k) — Updated Citizen Participation Plan and nationally recognized 2024–25 engagement (pop-ups, workshops, walking tours) that broadened representation; advisory input feeds planning/budget—Council makes the calls.

Davis, CA (~66k) — Robust advisory commissions framework; commissions lead public input for the upcoming General Plan update; open applications and targeted engagement pilots. Recommendations are advisory to the City Council.

Lawrence, KS (~95k) — Citywide Community Engagement commitment tied to the Strategic Plan, and a formal Citizen Participation Plan for Consolidated Plan work; all input is consultative to the elected City Commission.

Hypothetically Speaking…

What if every city across America adopted a Community Expert Advisory Panel approach?

What if major decisions were informed from diverse, informed local voices before votes were cast?

What if we cut reliance on consultants, saved taxpayer money, and still delivered better public engagement?

From Portland, Maine, to Portland, Oregon, communities could see higher trust, faster problem-solving, and smarter use of public funds. Not because we handed over power—but because we invited the public into conversation in a way that collaborates with elected officials, not against them.

That is the idea. And if Beloit, Janesville, or any other city chose to lead on this, they would not just be experimenting. Drawing on the best practices from cities like Santa Monica, Chapel Hill, Bellingham, Bloomington, Davis, and Lawrence, a refined Model Citizen Participation Plan—one that emphasizes strategic engagement, supports elected officials in their final decision-making roles, and brings in community expertise as a cost-effective alternative to paid consultants is a distinct possibility. Imagine the possibilities.

Why hire outsiders to tell you what your own neighbors already know? Let us put the wisdom of our community to work—together.

Why not be modeling what is possible for a stronger, more connected democracy?

Subscribe to Hypothetically Speaking for insight at the intersection of policy, people, and possibility.
New columns every Friday from Wisconsin’s heartland to America’s horizon.

☕ Community Spotlight: Havana Coffee

Fueling Dialogue, One Cup at a Time

Looking for a space to connect and reflect? Visit Havana Coffee at 1250 Milton Avenue true Janesville gem where civic energy meets excellent espresso. With hearty food, warm service, and a strong commitment to local journalism, Havana Coffee proudly supports the Rock County Civics Academy and all who believe in informed engagement.

💬 A Call to Leadership

Every advancement in our community begins with someone choosing to act. If you have asked yourself when the right time to get involved is—the answer might just be now.

Ways to contribute:
• Volunteer with a civic group
• Apply to serve on a local board or commission
• Run for public office and lead the change.

“If not me, who? If not now, when? — Hillel the Elder

Welcome our newest sponsor, Nowlan Law Firm and Attorney Tim Lindau. Thank you for sharing our vision for the future with your support today.

We deeply appreciate the support and encouragement from Tim at Nowlan, Daniela at Havana and many others who ask with us:

💭 Hypothetically Speaking…

What if transparency was standard in local government?
What if civic engagement became Rock County’s defining strength?

That is the mission of Hypothetically Speaking. And with your voice in the mix, it is closer to reality than ever.

🌐 Stay Engaged with the Rock County Civics Academy

📍 [Visit Our Website] rockcountycivicsacademy.org
📘 [Follow us on Facebook]
📺 [Subscribe on YouTube]
📰 [Join Our Substack Newsletter] Substack.com Key words: Rock County Civics Academy

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

No Tag